How long should I hang on to an investment?

Answer:

Even with a great financial advisor, you should be relatively savvy about your investment portfolio and how it works. And that includes knowing when to hold em and when to fold em. At a minimum, understanding the basics of investing will help you to determine the value of your advisors advice. And if you really want to take charge, you should know about risk and how to manage it intelligently.

You'll want to hang on to an investment as long as it meets your investment objectives, and you think it is likely to continue to perform as well as or better than comparable investments. Evaluating your investments once or twice a year will help you make that determination.

To evaluate your investments, you'll have to determine whether a particular investment is still appropriate for your age, risk tolerance, and financial goals. For example, perhaps you have been investing for retirement and have recently decided to purchase a home later this year. If a large part of your current investment portfolio is in a growth company stock fund, you should consider moving at least part of that investment to a less volatile investment, like a money market fund. Your investment goal has changed, and you'll need access to your investment dollars sooner rather than later. You certainly don't want to risk losing the down payment for your new home because of a sudden downturn in the markets.

A common mistake among investors is to hold on to an investment because it has fallen in value, hoping to earn your losses back before moving on. A good rule of thumb is that if you aren't willing to buy more of that investment at the lower value, it may be time to sell it. Just because the markets have historically gone up over time doesn't mean that an individual stock will go back up in value.

Aside from changes in your financial goals, a good time to re-evaluate an investment is when changes occur in the management of a mutual fund or company in which you own stock. You generally have no way of predicting what effect new management may have on the value of the securities. The additional risk or a change in investment objective, if any, may lead you to reconsider holding on to your shares.

Whenever you contemplate selling an investment, you may want to speak with a tax professional about the tax impact of the sale. You may decide to sell an investment that has performed poorly to offset gains in a given tax year. In contrast, you may want to hold on to an investment because selling it now may result in short-term capital gains treatment, whereas holding it for longer than a year will allow you to qualify for more favorable long-term capital gains treatment.


The 360 Degrees of Financial Literacy Web site offers general information for managing personal finances and does not recommend specific financial actions.  For financial advice tailored to your situation, please contact an expert such as a CPA or a personal financial advisor.